I grew up in a place where all four seasons feel very distinct, and I think that’s partly why I’ve always had such strong feelings about them. Early fall is one of my favorites. There’s something especially lovely about it.
I was born in the middle of August, and even around my birthday—or at least by the beginning of September—you can already feel that something is changing. The air smells different. The intense summer heat starts to disappear. And a little later, all that green slowly turns into gold, orange, rust, and yellow.
I love everything about it: the colors, the nature, the smell of the air, the comfortable temperature, and, of course, the cozy feeling that comes with the season.
And this is also the time of year when I start reaching for mystery shows and movies again.
I’ve always loved detective stories in pretty much every form, but there’s a particular kind of cozy mystery that has an almost calming effect on me. The crime itself is obviously not very cozy, but everything around it somehow is: the small towns, beautiful houses, bookstores and cafés, changing leaves, quiet streets, and amazingly scenic locations.
They’re the kind of mysteries I want to watch curled up under a blanket with something warm to drink.
So these are five of the ones I keep coming back to.
1. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries
![]() |
| Image courtesy of Hallmark Media |
Of course I have to start with Aurora Teagarden Mysteries.
This is probably the series I associate most strongly with this particular cozy-mystery feeling. Candace Cameron Bure plays Aurora, a librarian with a serious interest in true crime who somehow keeps finding herself in the middle of real murder investigations.
But a huge part of why I love rewatching these movies is the setting.
Although fictional Lawrenceton is presented as an American town, much of the original series was filmed around British Columbia, including Squamish, Langley, Abbotsford, and the Vancouver area. The building used as Lawrenceton Public Library is in Squamish, while several of Aurora’s homes and other recurring locations were filmed around Langley and Abbotsford. Even the waterfall that appears in the opening sequence is real: it’s Shequaga Falls in Montour Falls, New York.
And British Columbia really works for this series. The greenery, mountains, forests, houses, and small-town streets give it exactly the atmosphere I want from a cozy mystery.
Some installments become even more scenic. A Very Foul Play, for example, used locations around Whistler and Kelowna, while Honeymoon, Honeymurder includes Vancouver Island and the area around Cowichan Lake.
Honestly, I could probably rewatch this series for the locations alone.
2. Ainsley McGregor Mysteries
![]() |
Ainsley McGregor is a former criminologist who returns to the fictional small town of Sweet River, Texas, opens an artisan market, teaches criminology, and, unsurprisingly, starts getting involved in local murder investigations. The first movie, A Case for the Winemaker, revolves around a murder at a winery.
Despite the Texas setting, the first movie was filmed in Victoria, British Columbia, which explains why I immediately loved the scenery.
Victoria has that combination of historic architecture, greenery, quiet residential streets, water, and slightly old-fashioned charm that works so well for this kind of story. Later movies in the series have continued filming around Victoria and other parts of British Columbia.
3. Emma Fielding Mysteries
![]() |
| Image courtesy of Hallmark Media |
Emma Fielding Mysteries has a slightly different atmosphere from the others, and I think that’s why I like it so much.
Emma is an archaeologist rather than the typical librarian or bookstore-owning amateur sleuth, so the mysteries involve digs, history, old buildings, and secrets from the past.
And again, the locations are a huge part of the appeal for me.
Site Unseen, the first movie, was filmed around Sidney and Metchosin in British Columbia. Past Malice used Victoria and the beautiful Hatley Castle in Colwood, while More Bitter Than Death was also filmed around Vancouver and Victoria.
Hatley Castle in particular gives Past Malice such a gorgeous, almost old-world mystery atmosphere. It’s exactly the kind of setting where you expect someone to discover an old letter, a hidden room, or a family secret.
This series feels a little moodier than Aurora Teagarden, which makes it especially good for fall.
4. Fixer Upper Mysteries
![]() |
| Image courtesy of Hallmark Media |
Then there are the Fixer Upper Mysteries, starring Jewel as Shannon Hughes, a contractor and expert in restoring historic homes.
The whole premise is basically made for me: old houses + renovations + hidden secrets + murder mystery.
The fictional town is called Lighthouse Cove, and the movies were filmed primarily around Victoria and nearby communities in British Columbia. Framed for Murder used locations including Oak Bay, Victoria, Colwood, and the Fisgard Lighthouse, while Concrete Evidence includes Victoria’s Fisherman’s Wharf and a historic bed-and-breakfast used as Shannon’s home.
The houses might actually be my favorite part of this series. There are so many Victorian exteriors, old interiors, coastal views, and little details that make you want to pause the mystery and just look at the architecture.
Hallmark only made three of these, which I still think is a shame.
5. Family History Mysteries: Buried Past
![]() |
| Image courtesy of Hallmark Media |
The last one is slightly different because it isn’t really a series—at least not yet. It’s a single Hallmark movie called Family History Mysteries: Buried Past.
And I wish there were more.
The story follows Sophie McClaren, a genealogist who uses her research skills to investigate a family mystery, so it has that combination I always enjoy: present-day investigation mixed with pieces of the past.
It was filmed in Ottawa, Ontario, and I think the location is part of what makes the movie feel so cozy to me.
There’s something about Canadian cities and towns on screen that works especially well for this genre: the older architecture, tree-lined streets, changing seasons, and that slightly quieter visual atmosphere.
And this one has exactly the kind of mystery I like watching on a slow fall evening. It's interesting enough to keep me guessing, but comforting enough that I don’t finish it feeling stressed.
My kind of fall evening
I think that’s ultimately why I keep returning to these movies.
Yes, I like the mysteries. I want to know who did it. I like following the clues and trying to figure everything out before the characters do.
But sometimes I don’t need a complicated, dark crime drama. I just want a mystery, a beautiful setting, a blanket, and an evening when nothing particularly demanding is expected of me.
For me, that feels very much like fall.
What’s your comfort show when the weather starts getting cooler?
xoxo,
Sveta







